Friendscelebration cakescupcakes
wedding cake image

Celebration Cakes Menu

ordering your celebration cake

Ordering one of our yummy cakes is as simple as 1.2.3.

Choose: 1. Your flavor 2. Your size 3. Your inscription

We offer our standard Celebration Cakes in many sizes serving as few as 4 and as many as 100 or more!

Our 5“, 7”, 9“, 10” and 11“ cakes are round layer cakes, made with 4 layers of cake filled with three layers of buttercream (filling). The cakes are about 4.5–5" tall when finished.

  • The 1/4 sheet and 1/2 sheet cakes are rectangle layer cakes.
  • The 1/4 sheet is a two layer cake and is approximately 8" x 12" x 3".
  • The 1/2 sheet is offered in two layers: 11" x 16" x 3" or three layer cakes: 11" x 16" x 4".

We offer our celebration cakes in three flavor categories. Borders and an inscription in one color of your choice are included in the standard cake price.

1. Choose a flavor

classic flavors

  • Classic Vanilla: Classic vanilla buttercake filled and finished with creamy vanilla buttercream.
  • Vanilla and Chocolate: Classic vanilla buttercake filled and finished with our decadent chocolate fudge frosting.
  • Chocolate and Vanilla: Classic chocolate buttercake filled and finished with creamy vanilla buttercream.
  • Old Fashioned Chocolate Fudge: Classic chocolate buttercake filled and finished with chocolate fudge frosting.

deluxe flavors

  • Strawberry Cream: Vanilla buttercake layers are drizzled with fresh strawberry juice, then filled with our luscious strawberry cream. We can finish the cake in your choice of vanilla or strawberry buttercream.
  • Classic Coconut: Vanilla or chocolate layers are splashed with coconut cream, then filled with coconutty coconut cream. The cake is then finished in coconut cream and coated in moist shredded coconut.
  • Italian Cream: A classic wedding flavor, vanilla layers are studded with toasted pecans and coconut and filled and finished with our delicious cream cheese frosting.
  • Yummy Carrot Cake: Moist cinnamon tinged layers, chock full of freshly shredded carrots, toasted pecans, pineapple a nd currants, filled and finished with cream cheese frosting.
  • Red Velvet: A classic southern fave...these rich red layers are splashed with amaretto syrup, then filled and finished with our rich cream cheese frosting.
  • Mocha Mambo: If you love coffee...chocolate or vanilla layers are splashed with Kaluah liqueur, then filled with alternating layers of rich mocha cream and chocolate fudge frosting. The cake is then finished in more mocha cream.
  • Dulce de Leche: Vanilla or chocolate layers are filled with caramel cream, then drizzled with ooey gooey caramel, and finished in more caramel cream.
  • Lemon Heaven: Vanilla layers are sprayed with lemon syrup then filled and finished with lovely lemon buttercream.

super deluxe flavors

  • Strawberry “Shortcake“: Our classic vanilla layers are splashed with strawberry juice, then filled with strawberry cream and fresh chopped strawberries. We can finish this cake in your choice of vanilla or strawberry buttercream.
  • Lemon Raspberry: A favorite in spring and summer...vanilla layers are splashed with tangy lemon syrup, filled with creamy lemon buttercream smooshed with yummy fresh raspberries, then finished in lemon buttercream.
  • Orange Apricot Strawberry: A party in your mouth...vanilla layers are splashed with fresh orange juice, smeared with apricot jam, then filled with strawberry cream and chunks of ripe delicious strawberries. This cake can be finished in vanilla or strawberry buttercream.
  • Key Lime Coconut Mango: Like summer in a cake...vanilla layers are splashed with key lime syrup, then filled with mango cream and moist shredded coconut, and finished in more mango cream.
  • Chocolate Lovers': Nothing but chocolate...velvety chocolate layers are drizzled with Godiva Chocolate Liqueur, filled with dark, rich bittersweet chocolate ganache and fudge frosting, then finished in fudge frosting.
  • Just About Decadent: Chocolate layers are splashed with Gran Marnier, shmeared with a thin layer of apricot jam, then filled and finished with dark chocolate ganache or fudge frosting.
  • Chocolate Raspberry Cake: Delicious chocolate layers are splashed with raspberry liqueur, shmeared with a layer of tangy raspberry jam, then filled with layers of dark chocolate ganache and chocolate fudge frosting, studded with fresh juicy raspberries, then finished in chocolate fudge frosting.

flavor of the month

We offer at least one special cake flavor every month. Consult our website or one of our staff for details!

2. Choose a Size


3. Choose your inscription in the stock color of your choice

stock colors

  • Powder Blue
  • Pretty Pink
  • Bright Yellow
  • Lovely Lavender
  • Butter Yellow
  • Tangerine
  • Apple Red
  • Lime Green
  • Neon Pink
  • Chocolate Brown
  • Black
  • Navy Blue
  • White
  • Turquoise Blue
  • Royal Purple

Your buttercream or cream cheese finished cake is off-white in color. These can be TINTED any color. $10 per color; must provide a sample for color match.

for a more special look, choose one of our siz signature designs in two stock colors of your choice

signature cakes table

Please inquire about seasonal flavors and prices.

custom color matching

We can match most any color! Custom color matching is $5 per color, and a color sample must be provided.

still don't see what you're looking for?

custom artwork

To order your custom cake, first choose the size and flavor from our standard celebration cake menu, then we will add a Custom Art Charge on top of that.

If you know exactly what your are looking for, it is most helpful if you can provide the artwork when you order (or email the artwork to us). Anything you can do to save us time will save you money. Art charges will vary greatly depending on the difficulty of the design, research time, number of colors used and the size of your cake.

Even the simplest Custom artwork requires research, time and advanced decorating skills, and we need ample notice to prepare. During peak wedding season and holidays, we limit the amount of custom artwork orders that we take.

Custom cakes must be ordered at least one week in advance

Monograms and simple illustrations (baby rattle, graduation cap, martini glass, baseball, etc) are very popular and usually cost $10-20.

More complicated designs, such as matching an invitation, napkin or logo reproduction starts at $25.

It may be necessary to schedule a design consultation with one of our artists for more complicated cakes ($15 for a 30 minute consultation). Please ask one of our staff for more information.


We are so sorry Dora, Spongebob, Cinderella, Tinky Winky, et al!! We cannot risk duplicating copyrighted characters onto your cake. We can, however, include a character toy you bring in or decorate your cake to match the colors and style of your character theme.

Visit the Celebration Cakes Gallery

Visit the Celebration Cakes FAQ

Cupcakes Menu

Thank you for choosing Magpies!

Our award-winning cupcakes are made fresh daily, using the finest ingredients and lots of love. Choose from two sizes, MINI and REGULAR. The mini is the size of a mini muffin, approximately 2 bites for a delicate flower or small child and 1 for most dudes. The regular size is a standard cupcake (not jumbo) and is approximately 4 bites.

How many will you need?

We recommend ordering at least 2 per person for minis and one per person for regular size.

We keep dozens of minis and 6-packs of regulars in the case at all times. If you just need a few, choose a selection from our case. If you need a quantity or a specific flavor, please allow at least 24 hours notice. Our cupcakes may be ordered by the dozen only. Click on the cupcake menu to view it larger.

Cupcake Menu

standard cupcake add-ons

(available for mini and regular size)

Want to do something special? We can make your cupcakes stand out!

  • Tinted Icing
  • Please ask about tinting any flavor other than vanilla buttercream– $10 per color, $15 for custom color match
  • Specialty Liners
  • We have several fun designs to choose from: from $5/dozen
  • Seasonal Picks
  • Easter bunnies, Halloween ghouls, American flags, etc: from $2/dozen
  • Sugar Baby Booties
  • Oh, baby! available in pink, yellow and blue: $5/dozen
  • Single Initial or Message
  • Say it with cupcakes! Spell out Happy Birthday! or Marry Me! or just add a single initial on each cupcake
  • (please specify block or script and your color, or multi-colors) one letter per cupcake: from $5 dozen
  • Monogram Cupcakes
  • A popular choice for wedding and baby showers alike. Add a 3 letter monogram to each cupcake in the color or your choice. Specify block or script font: from $10/dozen (regular size only)
  • Sweet Bouquet of Cupcakes
  • Tiny sugarpaste flowers add a touch of spring to your selection. A variety of colors and styles to choose from. Extremely sweet! from $12/dozen
  • Stock Colors
  • powder blue, pretty pink, lovely lavender, butter yellow, tangerine, apple red, lime green, neon pink, chocolate brown, navy blue, white, turquoise blue, royal purple

customized cupcakes

It may be necessary to schedule a design consultation with our artist for more complicated custom cupcakes. ($15 for 30 minute consultation) Please ask one of our staff for more information.

(regular size only)

We can customize your regular size cupcakes for any occasion. Custom Art Charges start at $12 per dozen and go up depending on the complexity of the design and number of colors required. It is helpful if you provide clear artwork to go by. There is a an additional fee for researching an image. (we cannot draw copyrighted characters or images on cupcakes)

A minimum order of 3 dozen regular sized cupcakes is required for any custom art order. Please ask a staff member for details.

Caring for your cupcakes

Our cupcakes are baked fresh, and meant to be enjoyed the day they are purchased. If this is not possible, please store your cupcakes in an airtight container in the refrigerator, but make sure they are at room temperature when you eat them.


Though we have lots of customers who tell us they freeze our cupcakes with great success, we do not recommend it. Just buy fresh!

Baker's Dozen Club

Are you a frequent cupcake eater? Join our Baker's Dozen Club! It's FREE! Just fill out a card with your name and email and we'll keep it for you. Every time you buy a dozen mini cupcakes or a 6-pack of regulars from the case, we'll punch a cupcake on your card. When you buy 12, you get the 13th dozen free! You'll be first to know about the new flavors of the month, and will be invited to our Monthly Cupcake Tasting.

Visit the Cupcake Gallery

Visit the Cupcake FAQ

Return to Top